Why Eyelid-Specific Cleansers Are Better for Your Eyes Than Soap or Shampoo

Eyelid Cleansers, No Baby Shampoo

By Cheryl Chapman, OD

Dry Eye Specialist, and Chief Medical Officer, Peeq Pro

Most people assume their regular face wash or shampoo can clean their eyelids. After all, it’s “gentle,” right? But eyelids are not like the rest of the skin. They are some of the thinnest, most sensitive tissue on the body and home to the Meibomian glands—oil-producing glands that keep your tear film healthy and your eyes comfortable. Every day, the eyelid margins collect oil, dead skin, makeup residue, bacteria, and even microscopic Demodex mites. When this buildup isn’t removed correctly, it can lead to inflammation, clogged glands, styes, and chronic dry eye.

This is why modern eye care has moved away from recommending baby shampoo or regular facial cleansers for eyelid hygiene. Even “tear-free” formulas contain detergents, fragrances, sulfates, and preservatives made for the scalp and face—not for the delicate ocular surface. Research backs this up. In a 2017 randomized clinical trial published in Investigative Ophthalmology & Visual Science, eyelids cleaned with diluted baby shampoo showed more meibomian gland obstruction, poorer mucin markers, and reduced tear film quality, while the eyes cleaned with an eyelid-specific cleanser improved significantly.

Why regular soaps and shampoos fall short

  • They aren’t formulated for the pH of the eyelid margin or the tear film

  • They contain surfactants and preservatives that can irritate the ocular surface

  • Repeated use can worsen gland blockage

  • Some formulas may even affect goblet cell health, which plays a critical role in tear stability

Eyelid-specific cleansers, however, are engineered for the lash line and the Meibomian glands. They avoid harsh surfactants and irritating additives, and instead use mild, eye-safe cleansing agents that remove debris without disturbing the tear film.

What eyelid-specific cleansers do better

  • Clean effectively without damaging the tear film

  • Reduce bacterial and biofilm buildup

  • Remove mite debris and support healthier lashes

  • Improve meibum flow from the Meibomian glands

These benefits are supported by clinical research. A 2023 randomized clinical trial in the Journal of Clinical Medicine showed that low-concentration hypochlorous acid used twice daily significantly improved lid redness, meibomian gland function, and tear stability—with no adverse effects. Another study in contact lens wearers found that eyelid-specific cleansers improved comfort and tear film metrics more effectively and more quickly than baby shampoo.

For many people—makeup wearers, lash extension clients, contact lens users, allergy sufferers, and anyone with dryness or irritation—daily eyelid cleansing is one of the simplest and most effective ways to prevent flare-ups and maintain long-term comfort.

Eyelid cleansers were created by doctors specializing in dry eye and eyelid disease. Oil-based eyelid cleansers target debris and help address Demodex buildup, while hypochlorous spray soothes inflammation, supports the natural eyelid microbiome, and prepares the lash line for both hygiene and cosmetic treatments. Both formulas are designed for daily use and sensitive eyes.

The bottom line

  • Soap and shampoo were never designed for eyelid skin

  • The wrong cleanser can worsen dryness, irritation, and inflammation

  • Eyelid-specific cleansers protect the glands that keep your eyes comfortable

  • A healthy tear film starts with a clean, healthy eyelid margin

Your eyelids deserve their own cleanser—and your eyes will feel the difference.

References

Craig JP, Wang MTM, Cheung IMY, et al. Randomized paired-eye comparison of a commercial eyelid cleanser versus diluted baby shampoo for blepharitis management. Investigative Ophthalmology & Visual Science. 2017.

Zhang H, Wu Y, Wan X, et al. Effect of Hypochlorous Acid on Blepharitis through Ultrasonic Atomization: A Randomized Clinical Trial. Journal of Clinical Medicine. 2023;12(3):1164.

Khaireddin R, Hueber A. Eyelid hygiene for contact lens wearers with blepharitis: comparative investigation of treatment with baby shampoo versus phospholipid-liposome solution. Ophthalmologe. 2013.

FAQs

1. Can I use baby shampoo to clean my eyelids?

Baby shampoo has long been recommended, but newer research shows it can irritate the ocular surface, disrupt the tear film, and worsen Meibomian gland blockage. Eyelid-specific cleansers are formulated to avoid harsh surfactants and are safer for daily eyelid hygiene.

2. What’s the best cleanser for eyelids if I have dry eye?

Look for an eyelid cleanser formulated for sensitive eyes—typically hypochlorous acid sprays or gentle oil-based cleansers. These support the tear film, reduce inflammation, and improve Meibomian gland function without stripping natural oils.

3. Do eyelid cleansers help with eyelash mites (Demodex)?

Yes. Daily eyelid cleansing helps reduce debris and biofilm that allow Demodex mites to thrive. Oil-based eyelid cleansers are especially effective at dissolving buildup around the lashes, which supports healthier lids and lashes.

4. Are eyelid cleansers safe for people who wear makeup?

Absolutely. Eyelid-specific cleansers remove makeup residue, oil, and bacteria without damaging or irritating the lash line. 

5. Can eyelid cleansers help with blepharitis?

Yes. Blepharitis is often caused by oil buildup, bacteria, or mite debris on the eyelid margins. Studies show eyelid cleansers improve redness, irritation, and gland function more effectively than diluted soaps or shampoos.

6. How often should I clean my eyelids?

Most eye doctors recommend once to twice daily eyelid hygiene, especially if you have dry eye, wear contacts, or experience itching, burning, or irritation. Consistency is key for reducing flare-ups.

7. What ingredients should I avoid around my eyes?

Avoid cleansers containing sulfates, fragrances, parabens, and strong surfactants. These ingredients can disrupt the tear film, irritate the Meibomian glands, and worsen dryness.

8. Can eyelid cleansers help with itchy or burning eyes?

Yes. Many cases of itchy or burning eyes are caused by eyelid inflammation or clogged Meibomian glands. Regular eyelid cleansing removes irritants and helps restore a stable tear film, which can reduce discomfort.

9. Are hypochlorous acid sprays good for eyelid hygiene?

Hypochlorous acid (HOCl) is naturally antimicrobial and soothing. Clinical studies show it improves lid redness, tear stability, and symptoms of blepharitis with virtually no risk of irritation.

10. Do I still need an eyelid cleanser if I don’t wear makeup?

Yes. Even without makeup, the eyelids accumulate oil, debris, bacteria, and mite residue daily. Cleansing keeps the tear film healthy and prevents dryness, styes, and inflammation.

Back to blog